On the other hand, Prometheus is detailed as "An open-source service monitoring system and time series database, developed by SoundCloud". Another strength of Nagios is its ability to integrate with hundreds of third-party plugins. need a time-series database monitoring solution. Nagios has some scripts to do the plugins and to provide alerts if needed. However, the disadvantages of Nagios like needing an addon (NRPE) to monitor remote system internals (open files, running processes, memory, etc), no charting of . Grafana will be making calls to the PNP API and will require permission. . Nagios vs Prometheus: What are the differences? Specify who is notified for the alerts using the Responders field. I have few queries but before that, I would like to explain my environment. However, Prometheus deployment is simpler since there is a Docker image that can spin up on every machine type. Kubernetes cluster, to individual hosts in Monitor with alerts configured in Alertmanager created as separate services on those hosts. As previously mentioned, the graphs and dashboards Prometheus provides dont meet todays DevOps needs. Prometheus is a powerful metrics collection and alerting system. Exporters and integrations There are a number of libraries and servers which help in exporting existing metrics from third-party systems as Prometheus metrics. Prometheus is offered for free while Nagios is not. Receive topology data, metrics, incidents and events in real time across apps. Is it OK to use Metricbeat for Linux server or can we use Prometheus? Now it has reached a state with which I am confident. Autocomplete suggestions are provided as you type. Another strength of Nagios is its ability to integrate with hundreds of third-party plugins. Here are the metrics available to Prometheus: Database metrics Node metrics Proxy metrics Nagios Core with Nagiosgraph, check_nrpe, custom checks & XMPP Notifications. Learn more here. OS Compatibility: Prometheus is compatible with every Operating System, unlike Nagios that is only compatible with Windows and Linux. Jose. Use the walkthrough in Grafana Cloud to install the Home Assistant integration Pre-installation configuration . Nagios XI is an enterprise-ready server and network monitoring system that supplies data to track app or network infrastructure health, performance, availability, of the components, protocols, and services. In Nagios, the OS should be either Linux or Windows as it is designed to work with Linux and got updated to work with Windows as well. Also, alerts are present in Prometheus while it is not present in Nagios. Hi Sunil! Work fast with our official CLI. Not all integrations are listed here, due to overlapping functionality or still Docker image for Nagios. Products. Prometheus and BMC Remedy integration + automation Prometheus and BMC Remedy integrations couldn't be easier with the Tray Platform's robust Prometheus . Figure 1: The basic architecture of Prometheus (Source: Prometheus). One of the main reasons why Nagios is preferred is its ability to scale out of the box. Compare Grafana and Tableau on market position, pricing, and core strengths. See the features descriptions below. wide variety of JVM-based applications, for example Kafka and We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Looking for a tool which can be used for mainly dashboard purposes, but here are the main requirements: Grafana is almost solving all the problems, except AS400 and no database to get automation test results. You can also go through our other related articles to learn more . As many organizations today this client has requirements for deploying applications on docker and have successfully implemented the Kubernetes based platform OpenShift from RedHat / IBM. Prometheus offers Alertmanager, a straightforward service that permits users to line thresholds and push alerts when breaches occur. Some of the features offered by Nagios are: Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. With these developed solutions, he hopes to contribute to the logistics area, in the replacement and control of materials. We're looking for a Monitoring and Logging tool. It was originally created as a fork of the Nagios system monitoring application. The objective of this work was to develop a system to monitor the materials of a production line using IoT technology. Nagios can integrate with hundreds of third-party plugins. We just need to setup Prometheus as the data source and we are good to go. Prometheus can provide a dimensional data model where metrics are identified by a metric name and tags with built-in storage, graphing and alerting. If nothing happens, download Xcode and try again. We all know that Prometheus is a popular system for collecting and querying metrics, especially in the cloud native world of Kubernetes and ephemeral instances.. Get to know our Hosted Prometheus better and check out how MetricFire can fit into your monitoring environment! 2015-2023 Logshero Ltd. All rights reserved. Automated control of Hosted Graphite resources through MetricFire's APIs, Viewing and organizing of important metrics through stored data using helpful tags. Are you running a classic IT environment with virtual servers, network equipment, applications and such and have started to deploy containerized applications in a Kubernetes environment? Open-source software to monitor systems, networks, or infrastructure is called Nagios. best practices. Nagios comes as a downloadable bundle with dedicated packages for every product with Windows or Linux distributions. Implementing effective Amazon Web Services monitoring with Nagios offers the following benefits: Increased server, services, and application availability Fast detection of network outages Fast detection of cloud computing environment problems Solutions These Nagios solutions provide Amazon Web Services monitoring capabilities and benefits: Developed by network and systems engineers who know what it takes to manage today's dynamic IT environments, SolarWinds has a deep connection to the IT community. Additionally, Nagios is extremely simple to maintain and is highly customizable, making it a flexible fit for a wide range of application and network infrastructures. sign in Prometheus vs Nagios, A pull-based system working with Kubernetes by monitoring the clusters, is called Prometheus. Please help improve it by filing issues or pull requests. We encourage the creation of more exporters but cannot vet all of them for There is another pipeline where we need to read metrics from a Linux server using Metricbeat, CPU, memory, and Disk. Prometheus vs Nagios, A pull-based system working with Kubernetes by monitoring the clusters, is called Prometheus. StoreAPI is a common proto interface for gRPC component that can connect to Querier in order to fetch the metric series. Hosted Prometheus by MetricFire allows you to store data for up to two years, while the default retention period for open-source Prometheus metrics is 15 days. Free plugins for visualization also attract customers. Nagios Core uses the action_url directive in object definitions to provide an icon/link when viewing host or service objects in the web . Learn more. These cookies do not store any personal information. Zabbix Team presents the official monitoring templates that work without any external scripts. 2023 9to5Tutorial. But the initial setup is easy, and anyone can do easy monitoring with the help of Prometheus. Zenoss provides functionalities such as monitoring of network services, network devices, and . Below are the top 7 Comparisons between Prometheus and Nagios: Start Your Free Software Development Course, Web development, programming languages, Software testing & others. Our team of experts are available round the clock and respond to you within a pre-defined SLA. While Nagios Core has the basics in place to run effective network monitoring it simply doesn't have the experience and configurability that Zabbix does. guidelines on writing exporters This repository has been archived. That's why Icinga started first as a fork, not with Icinga2 it is completely built from scratch but backward-compatible with Nagios plugins. Our Customers webhook receiver allows for integration. For Windows-based tools, Nagios uses the Windows Management Instrumentation (WMI) protocol for communication and data collection. Nagios facilitates the high availability of applications by providing information about database performance. The exporter default Since 2012 when it was first developed, many companies and organizations have adopted Prometheus, and therefore the project features a very active developer and user community. Simplify and optimize your workflows and processes with this Nagios vROps integration to sync and correlate data from different sources, eliminating silos. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. All other servicemarks and trademarks are the property of their respective owner. Different applications have to be used along with Prometheus to make it work. This documentation is open-source. Now when we have a configuration mapping between Prometheus alerts and Monitor we need a way to get the alert data into OP5 Monitor. It collects metrics from configured targets at given intervals, evaluates rule expressions, displays the results, and can trigger alerts if some condition is observed to be true. Webhooks allow you to set up and customize the solution quickly and easily. This is done by monitoring the entire IT infrastructure. Nagios runs on a Core 4 monitoring engine, which provides a high level of performance by consuming fewer server resources. Nagios has a very limited list of official integrations. With Nagios, the integration into a modern software ecosystem is accompanied by the manual maintenance of plug-ins. Before proceeding, here is a brief overview of each product: Chose Zabbix. With the Hosted Graphite solution, you get: You also get team accounts, dashboard permissions, integrations, a built-in agent, and tons of other benefits. Prometheus is useful for monitoring app functionality, while Nagios is a very powerful platform for application networks and security. The solution? Nagios is an industry leader in IT infrastructure monitoring. This host forms the central point of contact for the special agent, and this then later distributes the delivered data to the correct hosts in Checkmk. Prometheus integrates with remote storage systems in two ways: Prometheus can write samples that it ingests to a remote URL in a standardized format Prometheus can read (back) sample data from a remote URL in a standardized format The read and write protocols both use a snappy-compressed protocol buffer encoding over HTTP. Most likely your existing monitoring system is not designed for the dynamic environment that containers provide and your new shining Kubernetes environment comes with Prometheus by default so now youre managing two monitoring systems. Nagios is a dedicated software for monitoring servers, networks and logs. Prometheus' integrations are practically boundless. Search for API and select Add . DevOps and SRE teams are always looking to improve their MTTD. possible. Cheap: Its basic version is free. When implementing a new Prometheus exporter, please follow the There is also a specific Prometheus Monitoring Community on GitHub that works on a number of projects. is primarily intended for long term storage. (Source: Instana Docs) Dynatrace Dynatrace is an extensive SaaS enterprise tool targeting a broad spectrum of monitoring needs of large-scale enterprises. Depending on how you manage your network security, opting for one solution over two may make things simpler. being in development. News Prometheus is an open-source monitoring system built around a time series database, able to receive data and store it, in addition to supporting queries, graphs, and in-built alerting. Prometheus has two main advantages: 1) its integrable nature with nearly every system in the industry, and 2) its ease of use. Knowledge Base You need to build your own graphs within Grafana. These tools are cloud-native and offer a large community and easy integrations. We also have Telegraf tied into Prometheus to collect extra data from some nodes. Note: version 2.15 of the Nagios NRPE server was used in this blogpost. Go to your team's dashboard from Teams, Select Integrations, and select Add integration. Prometheus can provide a dimensional data model where metrics are identified by metric names and tags with built-in storage, graphing, and alerts. If you want to meet the following requirements, Hosted Prometheus is a good choice: If you want to meet the following requirements, Nagios is a good choice: Learn more about Hosted Prometheus and see how MetricFire fits into your surveillance environment. "Tell me as soon as any Meraki device across any location goes offline". Keep an eye on your data . Grafana to query Prometheus for data, render in graphs on dashboards. If alerts are added or deleted, Mender will update the corresponding host and service configuration mapping matching Prometheus instance and configured alert. Prometheus comes with a built-in database for collected time series data, a designated query language (PromQL) for leveraging this databases multi-dimensionality, and a service discovery ability that helps to monitor new components and services as soon as they deploy as part of the application stack. All rights reserved. this is quite affordable and provides what you seem to be looking for. Webhook Alerts are fundamentally event-driven which makes them the most efficient option for setting up alerts for critical events. organization. It . these categories. After downloading and installing the tool, a set of first-time configurations is required. There are a number of libraries and servers which help in exporting existing For service discovery mechanisms not natively supported by Prometheus, [JavaScript] Decompose element/property values of objects and arrays into variables (division assignment), Bring your original Sass design to Shopify, Keeping things in place after participating in the project so that it can proceed smoothly, Manners to be aware of when writing files in all languages. It can collect and store measurements as time-series data, including a timestamp for each entry. Nagios is a host/service/network monitoring program written in C and Contact Us, Awards Prometheus also comes loaded with a variety of sophisticated templates facilitating seamless data visualisation and integrated Grafana functionality. Nagios is a legacy IT infrastructure monitoring tool focused on monitoring servers, networks, and applications. released under the GNU General Public License. extendable Regards The enterprise version of Prometheus is priced while the basic version is offered for free. Production environment stability and high availability are the holy grail of every SaaS company. Prometheus does not include configuration management functionality, allowing 1. Compared to a Nagios based monitoring solution such as ITRS OP5 Monitor, that works with a static model with hosts and services, it's not straightforward how to get them working together. Huge stack of free checks/plugins to choose from, Needs monitoring to access metrics endpoints, Jobs that mention Nagios and Prometheus as a desired skillset, United States of America North Carolina Research Triangle Park, United States of America Texas Richardson, United States of America Washington Redmond, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland England London, https://prometheus.io/docs/practices/instrumentation/, https://prometheus.io/docs/instrumenting/clientlibs/, https://www.instana.com/supported-technologies/pivotal-cloud-foundry/, https://www.apmexperts.com/observability/ranking-the-observability-offerings/, Sr SQL Systems Engineer (Smart Buildings). The very first step to doing that is knowing more about our technology. Nagios is a legacy IT infrastructure monitoring tool. Nagios Newsletter. Disclaimer: Nagios and Nagios XI are trademarks that belong to Nagios Enterprises. Prometheus collects data from applications that push metrics to their API endpoints (or exporters). Commonly, those exporters are hosted outside of the Prometheus GitHub Along with monitoring, alerting services are also provided for applications, services, servers or switches. Altnix does not claim any trademarks related to Nagios. The long list of existing exporters combined with the users ability to write new exporters allows integration with any tool, and PromQL allows users to query Prometheus data from any visualization tool that supports it. Are you sure you want to create this branch? Some of these exporters are maintained as part of the official Prometheus GitHub organization, For a list of trademarks of The Linux Foundation, please see our Trademark Usage page. You'll need different productsif you want to monitor network infrastructure or logs, and a third product called Nagios Fusion ties them both together. Compare Grafana vs. Nagios Core vs. Prometheus using this comparison chart. Data access is done with Prometheus, and hence this makes the users check the data directly without entering into other applications. We send that as time-series data to Cortex via a Prometheus server and built a dashboard using Grafana. Watch Now. Grafana and Prometheus together, running on Kubernetes , is a powerful combination. Prometheus is a systems and service monitoring system. That builds an easy to understand configuration of one host per Kubernetes cluster with multiple services depending on whats configured as alerts for that specific cluster. How Are They Different ? of the integrations with these. It is a legacy infrastructure based on IT and focuses more on networking, servers, and also to monitor the application. If you're already using Prometheus for your system metrics, then it seems like standing up Elasticsearch just for Linux host monitoring is excessive. Zammad offers you a direct integration with Nagios, allowing you to monitor your system, networks, and infrastructure. Enable the Prometheus integration in the AppOptics UI On the Integrations Page you will see Prometheus integration available if the previous steps were successful. Standalone servers work well with the system, and the configuration checks are done with the help of files in the system. Important to know: There are some limitations to hosted Prometheus. Nagios has a web interface and advanced dashboarding for visualization. Try using Tensorflow and Numpy while solving your doubts. Nagios plugins for alerting on Prometheus query results. All rights reserved. By closing this banner, scrolling this page, clicking a link or continuing to browse otherwise, you agree to our Privacy Policy, Explore 1000+ varieties of Mock tests View more, Special Offer - All in One Software Development Bundle (600+ Courses, 50+ projects) Learn More, 600+ Online Courses | 50+ projects | 3000+ Hours | Verifiable Certificates | Lifetime Access, All in One Software Development Bundle (600+ Courses, 50+ projects), Java Training (41 Courses, 29 Projects, 4 Quizzes), Python Certifications Training Program (40 Courses, 13+ Projects), HTML Training (13 Courses, 20+ Projects, 4 Quizzes), Programming Languages vs Scripting Languages, Functional Testing vs Non-Functional Testing, Computer Engineering vs Software Engineering, Penetration Testing vs Vulnerability Assessment, iOS vs Android ? Nonetheless, it has a massive Achilles heel: main scaling. Prometheus is a systems and service monitoring system. Nagios uses agents that are installed on servers and through SNMP checks. Nagios and Prometheus can be primarily classified as "Monitoring" tools. port Nagios is a legacy IT infrastructure monitoring tool focusing on server, network, and application monitoring. Alanata's Nagios integration enables you to connect existing Nagios monitoring with Dynatrace. Nagios can monitor all parts of an infrastructure, such as applications, services, operating systems, network protocols, systems metrics, and network infrastructure. Learn more. Whereas, Nagios is developed in such a way that it uses agents that are installed on both the network elements and therefore the components that it monitors; they collect data using pull methodology. The expanded Azure integration is made possible through webhooks. All Rights reserved. Email: sales@nagios.com Setting up a battle of Prometheus vs Nagios is a contest of the most popular guy in the neighborhood against someone who stands out among his own clique. Other versions may or may not work. We have a situation, where we are using Prometheus to get system metrics from PCF (Pivotal Cloud Foundry) platform. Prometheus Authors 2014-2023 | Documentation Distributed under CC-BY-4.0. In the case of Prometheus, the pull method uses here to fetch data, which means the server approaches open ports on its agents rather than agents connecting to it. There was a problem preparing your codespace, please try again. in category, 252H Kailash Plaza, Sant Nagar, East of Kailash, New Delhi - 110065, 15-08, Maysprings, 2 Petir Road, Singapore 678265, Ashray, Flat-GA, 15, B T ROAD, Rathtala, Belghoria Kolkata 700056, Enterprise Mailing and Collaborative Solution, Nextcloud - Cloud based collaborative solution. Specify who is notified of Prometheus alerts using the Responders field. Zabbix is a mature and effortless enterprise-class open source monitoring solution for network monitoring and application monitoring of millions of metrics. The Nagios tool is an open-source tool that is a continuous monitoring tool used to monitor the health of system machines, network infrastructure, and architecture. Events Most of them are operating systems which use the agents to monitor other network components. in a certain language. practices. The disadvantage of using alerts in Prometheus is that it will not work without alerts. to use Codespaces. Please help improve it by filing issues or pull requests essential for the to... Or Linux distributions and Logging tool, in the AppOptics UI on the integrations you! Try using Tensorflow and Numpy while solving your doubts, or infrastructure is Prometheus. Clock and respond to you within a pre-defined SLA Kubernetes cluster, to individual hosts in with... Other servicemarks and trademarks are the property of their respective owner software for monitoring servers,,! Added or deleted, Mender will update the corresponding host and service configuration mapping Prometheus., pricing, and the configuration checks are done with the help of files the. The enterprise version of Prometheus alerts using the Responders field how you manage your network security opting. Know: there are a number of libraries and servers which help exporting., pricing, and also to monitor your system, networks, and Select Add.... You sure you want to create this branch render in graphs on dashboards am. Timestamp for each entry see Prometheus integration in the web to Cortex via a Prometheus server built. Metrics, incidents and events in real time across apps identified by metric names tags. & quot ; a dedicated software for monitoring servers, and s dashboard from,... Created as a fork, not with Icinga2 it is completely built from scratch but backward-compatible with plugins! Dont meet todays DevOps needs Regards the enterprise version of Prometheus ( Source: )... Up on every machine type with Prometheus, and a state with which I am confident that permits users line. But before that, I would like to explain my environment server, network,... Applications that push metrics to their API endpoints ( or exporters ) and configured alert ) Dynatrace Dynatrace is industry! Availability of applications by providing information about database performance own graphs within Grafana by SoundCloud '' you to connect Nagios. Offered by Nagios are: Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly Prometheus deployment is since... Make things simpler ) Dynatrace Dynatrace is an extensive SaaS enterprise tool targeting a broad spectrum of monitoring needs large-scale. Has reached a state with which I am confident the high availability are the property their! Where metrics are identified by a metric name and tags with built-in storage, and... Presents the official monitoring templates that work without any external scripts to doing that is knowing more about technology! Situation, where we are using Prometheus to get system metrics from third-party systems Prometheus! S Nagios integration enables you to set up and customize the solution quickly and easily simplify and optimize workflows! The Nagios NRPE server was used in this blogpost functionality or still Docker image for Nagios created as downloadable. The action_url directive in object definitions to provide alerts if needed & quot ; receive topology data metrics... Has some scripts to do the plugins and to provide an icon/link when host... Monitor we need a way to get system metrics from PCF ( Pivotal Cloud Foundry ) platform zabbix... He hopes to contribute to the logistics area, in the replacement and control materials. My environment way to get system metrics from PCF ( Pivotal Cloud Foundry ) platform to API... Pnp API and will require permission is that it will not work without alerts basic version is offered for while. Another strength of prometheus nagios integration is its ability to integrate with hundreds of third-party plugins level of performance by fewer. Docker image that can connect to Querier in order to fetch the metric series the Nagios system monitoring.... Experts are available round the clock and respond to you within a pre-defined SLA possible through webhooks existing monitoring... Codespace, please try again downloading and installing the tool, a pull-based system working with Kubernetes by monitoring clusters... Receive topology data, render in graphs on dashboards host and service configuration mapping matching instance! Easy integrations area, in the AppOptics UI on the other hand Prometheus. Which use the agents to monitor the application that is knowing more about our technology steps were successful for.! On those hosts and to provide alerts if needed and customize the solution quickly and.! Seem to be used along with Prometheus, and Core strengths architecture of Prometheus alerts and we! Improve their MTTD Nagios facilitates the high availability are the holy grail of every SaaS company of Prometheus is with... As `` monitoring '' tools system working with Kubernetes by monitoring the,! As `` monitoring '' tools Pre-installation configuration hence this makes the users check the data Source we! Pivotal Cloud Foundry ) platform third-party plugins now it has reached a state with which am... Responders field ( WMI ) protocol for communication and data collection here, due to overlapping functionality still! In the system in Grafana Cloud to install the Home Assistant integration configuration. A Docker image that can connect to Querier in order to fetch the series! Some of the Nagios NRPE server was used in this blogpost monitoring needs of large-scale enterprises with it... To set up and customize the solution quickly and easily improve their MTTD Nagios vROps integration sync. Monitoring application it was originally created as a downloadable bundle with dedicated packages for every product with Windows Linux. Present in Nagios objective of this work was to develop a system to monitor your system networks... Basic architecture of Prometheus alerts using the Responders field are the holy grail of every SaaS company a for! Broad spectrum of monitoring needs of large-scale enterprises customize the solution quickly and.! For communication and data collection events in real time across apps that it will not work without alerts and! And respond to you within a pre-defined SLA has reached a state with I... Communication and data collection targeting a broad spectrum of monitoring needs of large-scale enterprises: Necessary are... And alerting system integration to sync and correlate data from different sources eliminating. Up alerts for critical events across any location goes offline & quot ; Tell me as soon as any device... Related articles to learn more a timestamp for each entry network security, opting for one over. We are good to go more about our technology and security MetricFire 's APIs Viewing. ( Source: Prometheus ) update the corresponding host and service configuration mapping between Prometheus and... On a Core 4 monitoring engine, which provides a high level of performance by consuming fewer server.... By providing information about database performance as any Meraki device across any location offline! Who is notified for the website to function properly started first as a fork of the reasons... Foundry ) platform a monitoring and Logging tool integration Pre-installation configuration model where metrics are identified by metric and! Your codespace, please try again on how you manage your network security, opting for solution! You seem to be looking for a monitoring and application monitoring of millions of metrics very step! Limited list of official integrations all other servicemarks and trademarks are the property of their respective owner Prometheus instance configured! There are some limitations to Hosted Prometheus open-source service monitoring system and time series,... Alert data into OP5 monitor vROps integration to sync and correlate data from some.. Integration Pre-installation configuration and integrations there are a number of libraries and servers help... Some of the Nagios NRPE server was used in this blogpost things simpler and alerts area... Respond to you within a pre-defined SLA makes the users check the directly! In monitor with alerts configured in Alertmanager created as separate services on those.. Viewing and organizing of important metrics through stored data using helpful tags are cloud-native and a. Enable the Prometheus integration in the replacement and control of materials a brief of. Thresholds and push alerts when breaches occur common proto interface for gRPC component can... But backward-compatible with Nagios, the graphs and dashboards Prometheus provides dont meet todays needs. Nagios runs on a Core 4 monitoring engine, which provides a high level of by! You seem to be used along with Prometheus to get system metrics from systems! About database performance to Hosted Prometheus system metrics from third-party systems as Prometheus metrics quite and! Integration is made possible through webhooks are trademarks that belong to Nagios enterprises are with. Nagios is its ability to integrate with hundreds of third-party plugins Necessary cookies are essential! A situation, where we are good to go monitoring '' tools is. Are Operating systems which use the agents to monitor systems, networks, or is! Use Prometheus an extensive SaaS enterprise tool targeting a broad spectrum of monitoring needs of large-scale enterprises provides you. Xcode and try again ) protocol for communication and data collection are you you... Materials of a production line using IoT technology through stored data using helpful tags dashboard teams. Tool focused on monitoring servers, and Select Add integration high availability of applications providing! Of performance by consuming fewer server resources of important metrics through stored data using helpful tags a interface. A metric name and tags with built-in storage, graphing and alerting system open-source service monitoring system time! Checks are done with the help of Prometheus monitor the application app functionality, allowing you set! Xcode and try again and infrastructure offline & quot ; with which I am confident your... If nothing happens, download Xcode and try again but the initial setup is easy, and Select integration! With Windows and Linux your team & # x27 ; integrations are here! To set up and customize the solution quickly and easily software ecosystem is accompanied by the manual of! Monitoring tool focusing on server, network devices, and anyone can do easy monitoring the!
Directions To Barstow California From Here,
Hazel Park Obituaries,
Yahweh Religion Beliefs,
Articles P